Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr. Sophie Lenoir's avatar

Great post. I know a man who routinely walks into rooms full of senior leaders in ill-fitting and crumpled clothes and still manages to impress everyone. What this tells me is not that he is particularly brilliant (although he is) or particularly laid back. What this tells me is that he is so completely secure in his own belonging in that room that he knows they will take him seriously no matter what he wears. That security is the definition of privilege.

Whereas women, people with a different accent, people from a different social class, anyone who doesn't look like they were born to sit in that room, learn that they do have to dress the part or use the title, not necessarily because they care more about status, but because they have found through experience that people just look through them if they don’t. You can call it insecurity or poor taste but I think it's often just an adaptation to how the world responds.

Bart Claus's avatar

Here's a different take. I have no idea whether it is correct, because I too was not born into a Phd, but I do wonder whether things are as straightforward as they might seem in this case.

So: you are proud of your achievements, and rightfully so, as far as I am concerned. Now imagine being born in a family where those same achievements are not achievements, but things completely taken for granted. In other words, in such an environment, people might not hang up their diploma because they cannot take pride in the achievements represented by them, because those achievements are not seen by their context as special. For example, even though for millions of people around the world getting one would be an extraordinary achievement without precedent in their family, you and me don't hang up our driver's license, right?

So: maybe they take less pride, because they are less proud? And maybe you are therefore better off? And maybe it is a good idea to show that these achievements are in fact something to be proud of by continuing to hang up your diploma? I have no idea whether all this is accurate, but it's worth considering I think.

PS: All that said, I am of the opinion that being an academic is not something that happens at one point, e.g. when you get a degree, but every day. For example, by writing the excellent blog you do (thanks for that).

4 more comments...

Ready for more?