Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr. Jeff Perron, C.Psych's avatar

Nice piece. Your articulation of Quebec's culture and "specialness" map onto my experience living next to, and visiting, often, Quebec.

...had to laugh at the picture...especially the above-ground pools.

Expand full comment
Ivan Fyodorovich's avatar

Honestly, as a Jewish Montrealer I totally get Quebecois obstreperousness. I inconvenience others and sacrifice economic utility through my badly timed fall and spring holidays, peculiar dietary restrictions, and refusal to live in neighbourhoods that lack Jewish communal life. Wouldn't it be more convenient for everyone if I just became more like everyone else? Yes, but I would sooner die. I totally get why the Quebecois would rather sabotage their economy than abandon their language and culture.

The other dynamic I notice is that recent immigrants like me tend to be rather accepting of Quebec language laws. If you move to Tokyo your kids learn Japanese, if you move to Quebec they learn French. The angry anglophones are people like you who grew up in the city only to be told that they are unwelcome and unwanted. I sympathize with that too.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts